Fender Rumble 800 HD vs EVH 5150 Iconic 40W
Quick Verdict
Choose the Fender Rumble 800 HD if you are a bassist who wants a very light 5.8 pound head with a published 800 watts, XLR pre-master out, headphone output, and aux input. It requires an external speaker cabinet and has only a switchable overdrive. Choose the EVH 5150 Iconic 40W if you are a guitarist seeking two channels of classic high gain tube tone in a 1x12 combo with a built-in noise gate and power reduction. The EVH lacks a headphone out and published weight. Neither offers Bluetooth, app control, or a broad effects suite. Pick based on your instrument and whether you need a bass head or a guitar combo.
| Spec | Fender Rumble 800 HD | EVH 5150 Iconic 40W |
|---|---|---|
| Power output | 800 watts (published as 800-Watt amplifier head) | 40 watts as listed |
| Speaker | Not published in listing; amplifier head requires external speaker cabinet | 1x12 inch, speaker brand and model not published in listing |
| Amp models or channels | Not published in listing; includes three-button tone voicing and switchable overdrive | 2 channels |
| Effects | Switchable overdrive circuit (only effect listed) | Noise gate only, no other effects listed |
| Inputs and outputs | Stereo aux input; XLR line out (pre-master) with ground lift switch | Speaker-emulated output mentioned, other inputs and outputs not published |
| Headphone and line out | Stereo headphone output; XLR line out with ground lift switch | Not published in listing, speaker-emulated output may serve as a line out but is not described as a headphone out |
| Bluetooth and app | Not published in listing; no Bluetooth or app mentioned | Not published in listing |
| Weight | 5.8 lbs | Not published in listing |
| Dimensions | Not published in listing | Not published in listing |
| Included accessories | Not published in listing; listing title mentions 2-year warranty | Not published in listing |
Amp Models and Tone
The Fender Rumble 800 HD does not list specific amp models or channels in the published specs. It includes a three-button tone voicing system and a four-band EQ, which gives bassists flexible tone shaping without digital modeling. The listing also mentions a switchable overdrive circuit, so the head can add a driven bass tone. The tone sub score is 27 out of 30, reflecting strong foundational bass tone tools rather than a large model library.
The EVH 5150 Iconic 40W lists two channels, which provide clean and overdrive tones. Its high gain tone is the main selling point, built around the classic EVH 5150 voicing and an all tube power section. The tone sub score is 29 out of 30, the highest sub score in this comparison. The listing does not mention other amp models or digital modeling, so players get two core sounds instead of a menu of models.
Effects and Features
The only effect listed for the Fender Rumble 800 HD is a switchable overdrive circuit. It does not include a built in tuner, compressor, or any other effects, which keeps the signal path simple. The effects sub score is 16 out of 20, reflecting the absence of a broader effects suite. For bassists who rely on external pedals this is acceptable, but players wanting integrated modulation or delay will need separate units.
The EVH 5150 Iconic 40W has only a built in noise gate and no other effects are published. This noise gate is specifically useful for tightening high gain rhythm tones and reducing hiss, but it does not color the sound. The effects sub score is 10 out of 20, which is lower than the Fender. Both amps are minimal in effects, so neither is an all in one solution and both assume external pedals for anything beyond a single effect.
Power, Speaker and Volume
The Fender Rumble 800 HD publishes an 800 watt power output, which is very high for a bass head. It does not include a speaker cabinet, so the player must supply an external cabinet. The power sub score is a perfect 15 out of 15 because the wattage is substantial. The listing does not publish the speaker impedance or the recommended cabinet, but the head weighs only 5.8 pounds. Actual volume depends on the cabinet used.
The EVH 5150 Iconic 40W publishes a 40 watt all tube power section and includes a 1x12 inch speaker. The speaker brand and model are not published in the listing. The power sub score is 12 out of 15, lower than the Fender, but 40 watts is typical for a tube guitar combo. It includes a power reduction circuit for lower volume operation, which helps in home settings. The single 12 inch speaker may limit low end compared to larger cabinets, but the listing does not provide frequency response data.
Build and Portability
The Fender Rumble 800 HD weighs 5.8 pounds, but its dimensions are not published. The build sub score is 8 out of 10. The light weight is a major advantage for transport, especially for a bass amplifier. The listing mentions a magnetic attachment for Rumble cabinets, which simplifies setup. Without dimensions, the footprint cannot be assessed, but the head is clearly very portable based on weight alone.
The EVH 5150 Iconic 40W does not publish its weight or dimensions. The build sub score is also 8 out of 10, but direct portability comparison is impossible. Because it is a combo with a tube power section and a 12 inch speaker, it is likely heavier and bulkier than a bare head, but the listing does not confirm this. The Fender clearly wins on published weight, while the EVH remains an unknown for players who need to carry it regularly.
Connectivity and Apps
The Fender Rumble 800 HD lists a stereo aux input, a stereo headphone output, and an XLR pre-master line out with a ground lift switch. The connectivity sub score is 13 out of 15. These connections are useful for silent practice, playing along with tracks, and sending a direct signal to front of house. No Bluetooth or app support is mentioned in the listing. The ground lift helps reduce hum in live settings.
The EVH 5150 Iconic 40W mentions a speaker-emulated output, but other inputs and outputs are not published. The connectivity sub score is 10 out of 15. No headphone output, aux input, Bluetooth, or app support is listed. The speaker-emulated output may be usable for direct recording or feeding a PA, but the listing does not specify the connector type or whether it doubles as a line out. The Fender offers more clearly documented connectivity.
Setup and Daily Use
Setting up the Fender Rumble 800 HD requires an external speaker cabinet. The magnetic attachment to Rumble cabinets makes mounting quick, but a cabinet is still needed for audible sound. For daily practice, the headphone output and aux input allow quiet playing, though the listing does not state if the head can operate safely without a speaker load connected. The controls are straightforward with a four-band EQ, three-button voicing, and switchable overdrive. There is no app to configure.
The EVH 5150 Iconic 40W is simpler to set up because it is a combo with a built in 12 inch speaker. You can plug in and play immediately. The power reduction circuit helps keep volume manageable for daily use at home. It has two channels and a noise gate, so switching between clean and high gain is easy. No headphone output is listed, so silent practice is not supported by the published features. Weight and dimensions are unknown, which makes moving the amp daily uncertain.
Home Practice Versus Stage
For home practice, the Fender Rumble 800 HD supports silent playing through its headphone output and has an aux input for backing tracks. However, the listing does not clarify if a speaker cabinet is required for safe operation, so players may need to keep a cabinet connected. The high power is not needed at home but can be turned down, though no power reduction circuit is mentioned. The EVH 5150 Iconic 40W has a power reduction circuit for lower volume operation, which is useful at home, but it lacks a headphone output, so it is not silent.
On stage, the Fender Rumble 800 HD has 800 watts and an XLR pre-master out with ground lift, which is ideal for live bass. The head is light to carry at 5.8 pounds and can connect directly to front of house. You still need a speaker cabinet for stage monitoring unless using in-ear monitors, but the XLR can feed the PA. The EVH 5150 Iconic 40W has 40 watts and a speaker-emulated output, which can work for small stages or as a monitor, but the single 12 inch speaker may not fill larger rooms without PA support.
The Deciding Question
The core question is whether you are a bassist or a guitarist. The Fender Rumble 800 HD is a bass amplifier head, and the EVH 5150 Iconic 40W is a guitar combo. That single factor drives most of the decision. If you play bass and already own a speaker cabinet, the Fender is the relevant choice. If you play guitar and want the EVH high gain tone, the 5150 is the obvious pick.
Secondary questions involve connectivity and practice needs. The Fender offers a headphone output, aux input, and XLR out, making it more flexible for silent practice and direct recording. The EVH offers power reduction and a noise gate, but no headphone or aux input. Neither amp has built in effects beyond one circuit each. If you require Bluetooth, app control, or a large effects suite, neither amp satisfies that need. Choose based on your instrument and your primary use case.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the Fender Rumble 800 HD if you are a bassist who needs a lightweight, high power head for stage and studio work. It fits players who already have a bass cabinet or want a compact head with a direct XLR out. The headphone and aux inputs make it suitable for home practice. It is not for guitarists or for bassists who want a self contained combo with a broad built in effects suite.
Buy the EVH 5150 Iconic 40W if you are a rock or metal guitarist who wants a compact tube combo with authentic high gain tone and a power reduction circuit. It fits players who use external pedals for effects and do not need headphone practice. It is not for bassists or for those who need a wide range of built in effects and connectivity options. The listing's missing weight and dimensions may matter if portability is a critical factor.
Fender Rumble 800 HD
Pros
- Very high 800-watt power rating
- Extremely light at 5.8 pounds
- Pre-master XLR out with ground lift
- Stereo aux input and headphone output
- Four-band EQ and three-button tone voicing
- Magnetic attachment for Rumble cabinets
Cons
- No speaker cabinet included
- No Bluetooth or app support listed
- No built-in tuner or compressor listed
- Limited onboard effects beyond overdrive
- Dimensions and cabinet impedance not published
EVH 5150 Iconic 40W
Pros
- 40 watt all tube power with a 12 inch speaker
- Dual channels for clean and overdrive tones
- Power reduction circuit allows lower volume operation
- Speaker emulated output for direct recording or front of house
- Built in noise gate helps tame high gain hiss
- Classic EVH 5150 high gain heritage at a mid range price
Cons
- Listing omits weight, dimensions and exact speaker model
- No built in reverb, delay or modulation effects
- No headphone output or Bluetooth app support mentioned
- Single 12 inch speaker may limit low end compared to larger cabs
- Unknown input and output connectivity beyond speaker emulated output
Who Should Buy Each
Fender Rumble 800 HD
- Working bassists who need high clean headroom
- Players using Fender Rumble speaker cabinets
- Musicians who value a light and portable rig
- Home players who want headphone practice with an aux input
EVH 5150 Iconic 40W
- Players who prioritize high gain tube distortion
- Guitarists who record direct with speaker emulation
- Home users who need power scaling to control volume
- Fans of the EVH 5150 series who want a combo version
Quick Decision Guide
| If you are a bassist who needs a lightweight 5.8 pound head with 800 watts and an XLR out for front of house | Choose Fender Rumble 800 HD |
| If you are a guitarist who wants classic EVH 5150 high gain tone with two channels and a 1x12 speaker | Choose EVH 5150 Iconic 40W |
| If you need a headphone output and aux input for silent practice with backing tracks | Choose Fender Rumble 800 HD |
| If you want a combo with a built in noise gate for tight metal rhythm and a power reduction circuit for home volume | Choose EVH 5150 Iconic 40W |
| If you already own a bass cabinet and want a portable high power head to carry to gigs | Choose Fender Rumble 800 HD |
FAQ
About This Comparison
Mandrillis Team
The Mandrillis editorial team researches and compares audio and music gear using manufacturer documentation, verified specs and real buyer feedback, so you can make a confident purchase without wading through marketing claims.
Read our full research methodology.
We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.