Grote Semi-Hollow vs Redid RD-100
Quick Verdict
The Grote Semi-Hollow scores 64 out of 100, slightly above the Redid RD-100 at 60, but the difference is small. Choose the Grote if you want a semi-hollow platform with stainless steel frets and a comfortable 24.75 inch scale and are willing to accept unspecified pickups and hardware. Choose the Redid if you prefer a defined dual humbucker setup with independent volume and tone controls and a rosewood fretboard, despite similar hardware unknowns. Both suit practice and light gigging on a budget. Neither is a good choice for buyers who require complete specifications before purchase, but each offers a low cost entry into semi-hollow territory.
| Spec | Grote Semi-Hollow | Redid RD-100 |
|---|---|---|
| Body | Semi-hollow Canadian maple body | Semi-hollow body with F-hole, brown finish |
| Neck and fingerboard | Maple neck with black wood fingerboard | Canadian hard maple neck with rosewood fretboard |
| Scale length | 24.75 inches | 24.75 inches |
| Frets | 22 stainless steel frets | Stainless steel frets, number not published in listing |
| Pickups | Not published in listing | Dual humbuckers, brand and output not published in listing |
| Controls | Not published in listing | 3-way toggle switch, 2 volume knobs, 2 tone knobs |
| Bridge | Not published in listing | Not published in listing |
| Tuners | Not published in listing | Not published in listing |
| Finish | Not published in listing | Brown |
| Included accessories | Not published in listing | Not published in listing |
Body, Neck and Playability
Both guitars feature semi-hollow bodies. The Grote lists a semi-hollow Canadian maple body, while the Redid states a semi-hollow body with an F-hole and a brown finish. Neither listing provides body weight or depth, so the actual feel is unknown. The maple body on the Grote suggests a bright and resonant foundation, while the Redid's F-hole is a traditional semi-hollow feature that may enhance acoustic response.
The necks on both are maple, but the Redid specifies Canadian hard maple, a more detailed descriptor often associated with stability. The Grote only says maple neck, without grade or hardness information. For fingerboards, the Grote uses an unspecified black wood, while the Redid uses a rosewood fretboard, known for a smoother and warmer feel. Neither listing states the neck profile or fingerboard radius.
Both share a 24.75 inch scale length, which is comfortable for many players. The Grote explicitly lists 22 stainless steel frets, while the Redid says stainless steel frets but does not publish the count. The Redid's pros mention a 42mm nut width, but the spec table does not include that measurement. Overall, both offer a similar comfortable scale and durable fret material, but the Grote provides more specific fret count information.
Pickups and Tone
The pickup situation separates these two models significantly. The Grote listing does not publish any pickup details, so the type, output, and tone character are completely unknown. The Redid listing states that it has dual humbuckers, though the brand and output are not published. Dual humbuckers typically produce a thicker, warmer tone with less noise than single coils, but without output specs, the exact character remains uncertain.
The control layouts also differ in published information. The Redid has a 3-way toggle switch, two volume knobs, and two tone knobs, a familiar setup for blending two humbuckers. The Grote does not list any control configuration, so it is impossible to know whether it has a similar switch or how many knobs are present. This lack of information makes it hard to predict how the Grote can shape its tone, while the Redid at least offers a standard dual humbucker control scheme.
For tone expectations, the Grote's semi-hollow maple body is listed as offering a warm, resonant tone, but that acoustic property will only partially translate through unknown pickups. The Redid's humbucker design is generally suited for jazz, blues, and classic rock, which matches its best for description. Buyers who want a predictable electric tone have more to go on with the Redid, even though the pickup brand is not disclosed.
Hardware and Electronics
Both guitars have significant gaps in their published hardware specs. Neither listing names the bridge type or the tuners brand and ratio. This means buyers cannot assess tuning stability or intonation adjustment quality from the spec sheet. The Grote does not list any hardware or electronics information at all, including the type of switch or pots. The Redid at least publishes its control configuration, which gives some confidence in the electronics, but the bridge and tuners remain unknown.
The Redid's electronics include a 3-way toggle switch and independent volume and tone controls for each pickup. This is a standard and serviceable layout that allows basic tone shaping. The Grote's electronics are unspecified, so it is unclear whether it has a toggle, how many knobs, or if it uses a simpler wiring scheme. Without this information, the Redid appears to have an advantage in electronics, but the unknown bridge and tuners still apply to both.
Neither guitar lists included accessories such as a case, cable, strap, or tools. This is common in the budget tier, but it means buyers may need to budget for these separately. The absence of published hardware details also suggests that upgrades might be necessary for players who want reliable tuning or a more adjustable bridge. Both models include stainless steel frets, which are a positive hardware feature, but the rest of the hardware remains a question mark.
Build Quality and Finish
The Grote lists a semi-hollow Canadian maple body but does not state the finish color or type. The Redid specifies a brown finish, which is a known aesthetic choice, but does not describe the finish material or gloss level. Build quality in the budget tier can vary, and both listings include cons that acknowledge this risk. The Grote's cons explicitly mention potential setup inconsistencies common at this price point, while the Redid's cons note unknown quality control for the budget tier.
Both guitars use maple necks, but the Redid's Canadian hard maple is a more specific descriptor that suggests a harder and more stable wood. The fingerboards differ: the Grote uses an unspecified black wood, which could be a dyed hardwood or a composite, while the Redid uses rosewood, a traditional choice known for its smooth feel. Neither listing provides information about fret installation quality, nut material, or body binding, so overall build finish cannot be fully judged.
The presence of stainless steel frets on both is a positive durability indicator, as they resist wear better than nickel silver frets. However, fret work quality at the budget tier is not guaranteed, and neither listing claims a professional fret level or crown from the factory. The Redid's brown finish and F-hole add visual appeal, while the Grote's metallic truss rod cover is a small cosmetic detail but does not affect playability. Buyers should expect that some setup and adjustment may be needed on either instrument.
Setup Out of the Box
Neither listing promises a professional setup out of the box, and both are budget priced instruments where factory setup can be inconsistent. The Grote's cons list potential setup inconsistencies as a common issue, while the Redid's cons mention unknown quality control. This suggests that action height, neck relief, and intonation may need adjustment after unboxing. Players who are comfortable performing a basic setup or paying a technician will be less affected by this risk.
The published specs do not include any setup details such as string gauge, action measurements, or factory tuning. Both guitars have stainless steel frets, which are often installed level if the factory quality control is good, but this cannot be assumed. The Redid's 24.75 inch scale and 42mm nut are listed as comfortable on paper, but the actual playability still depends on the setup. The Grote's shorter scale and stainless frets should also be comfortable, but without fret count or nut width, the feel is less certain.
Because neither listing states included accessories like a case or cable, there is no indication that the guitar ships with a setup tool or instructions. In the budget tier, it is common for the guitar to arrive with strings that may need replacing and a neck that needs relief adjustment. Buyers who want a ready to play instrument out of the box may find both of these risky. Those who treat the purchase as a project or platform will be more satisfied.
Daily Use and Practice
For daily practice, both guitars offer a comfortable 24.75 inch scale length, which reduces string tension and reach compared to a 25.5 inch scale. This can make chording and bending easier for many players. The stainless steel frets on both should hold up well to frequent playing without excessive wear. The semi-hollow bodies may produce some acoustic volume, which is nice for unplugged practice, though neither listing states the exact acoustic volume or weight.
The Redid has a published control layout with independent volume and tone knobs and a 3-way switch. This allows a player to quickly adjust tone between practice exercises or songs without needing to know the pickup specifics. The Grote's lack of published controls means the owner may need to experiment to find usable settings, or possibly rewire the guitar. For daily use where quick adjustments matter, the Redid's known layout is an advantage, though its bridge and tuners remain unknown.
Neither listing mentions the weight of the guitar, which is important for long practice sessions. Semi-hollow guitars are often lighter than solid body models, but without published weight, this cannot be confirmed. Both guitars are described as budget tier, so the overall build should be adequate for home practice and light use. The absence of included accessories means the buyer should have a cable, strap, and possibly a stand ready, as neither listing confirms these are in the box.
Versatility and Styles
Both instruments are semi-hollow electric guitars, a design typically associated with jazz, blues, and classic rock. The Redid's listing explicitly states it suits jazz, blues, and rock, and its dual humbuckers are a standard choice for those styles. The Grote's best for description mentions practice and light gigging without naming specific genres, but its semi-hollow maple body can also work for many styles. However, versatility ultimately depends on the pickups, which are unknown for the Grote and only partially known for the Redid.
The Redid's standard control setup with a 3-way switch and two volume and two tone knobs gives a player the ability to blend pickups and roll off highs or lows, which adds to its versatility. The Grote's controls are unpublished, so it is impossible to say whether it offers similar flexibility. If the Grote has a simpler wiring scheme, it might be less versatile for tone shaping. On paper, the Redid has a clearer path to covering jazz, blues, and classic rock, while the Grote is more of an unknown.
Both guitars have stainless steel frets and a 24.75 inch scale, which are versatile features for bending, chording, and fast playing. The semi-hollow construction is commonly used for cleaner tones and moderate overdrive, but neither listing provides specific feedback resistance ratings. For buyers who want a versatile budget guitar for multiple styles, the Redid's known humbucker configuration provides a slight edge, but both require acceptance of unspecified hardware details.
The Deciding Question
The Grote Semi-Hollow scores 64 out of 100 in the supplied breakdown, while the Redid RD-100 scores 60. The four point difference is small and mostly due to the Grote's slightly better hardware and electronics score, but both are limited by missing information. The deciding question for a buyer is whether you can accept fully unspecified pickups and controls on the Grote, or whether you prefer at least a defined dual humbucker layout on the Redid.
If you are comfortable doing a setup and possibly upgrading pickups, the Grote offers an intriguing semi-hollow maple body and 22 stainless steel frets at a budget price. The unknown hardware, including bridge and tuners, is a risk, but many budget players expect to replace these parts. The Redid, by contrast, gives you a standard control scheme and a rosewood fretboard, which may feel more familiar out of the box, though its bridge and tuners are just as unspecified.
Ultimately, the purchase decision hinges on how much published information you need before buying. If you require detailed specs on pickups, bridge, and tuners, neither guitar will satisfy you, and you should look at established models with full documentation. If you are willing to gamble on a budget semi-hollow with good bones, the Grote's slightly higher score and specific fret count make it a reasonable pick. If you want the assurance of humbuckers and standard controls, the Redid is the safer choice despite its lower score.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the Grote Semi-Hollow if you want an affordable semi-hollow electric with a Canadian maple body, maple neck, and 22 stainless steel frets. This guitar is best for players who do not mind unspecified pickups and hardware and are willing to perform a setup or upgrade parts later. It is a platform for practice and light gigging where the durable frets and comfortable scale length are the main selling points.
Buy the Redid RD-100 if you want a budget semi-hollow with a traditional dual humbucker setup and a standard control layout. The published 3-way switch, two volume knobs, and two tone knobs make it easier to dial in jazz, blues, or classic rock tones without guessing. The rosewood fretboard and brown finish are known features, which adds some confidence. This model suits players who want a semi-hollow for familiar styles and accept that the bridge, tuners, and pickup brand are not disclosed.
Avoid the Grote if you cannot buy a guitar without knowing the pickup type, control configuration, or bridge design. Avoid the Redid if you need complete hardware specs and pickup output details before purchase. Both are budget instruments with unknown quality control, so neither is ideal for buyers who expect a perfect out of box experience. However, for the right player, each offers a unique entry point into semi-hollow territory at a low price.
Grote Semi-Hollow
Pros
- Semi-hollow Canadian maple body offers warm, resonant tone
- 24.75 inch scale length is comfortable for many players
- Maple neck with black wood fingerboard provides smooth feel
- 22 stainless steel frets resist wear and provide reliable intonation
- Budget price tier makes it accessible
- Metallic truss rod cover adds visual detail
Cons
- Pickups are not specified, so tone character is unknown
- Bridge and tuners are unspecified, making hardware quality uncertain
- No included accessories listed, such as case or cable
- Potential setup inconsistencies common at budget tier
- Finish options not described, limiting aesthetic certainty
Redid RD-100
Pros
- Semi-hollow construction suits jazz, blues, and rock
- 24.75 inch scale and 42mm nut offer comfortable feel on paper
- Stainless steel frets promise durability
- Dual humbuckers with independent volume and tone controls
- Rosewood fretboard adds traditional warmth
- Budget price tier
Cons
- Pickup brand and output are unpublished
- Bridge and tuner specs are not stated
- No included accessories listed
- Limited finish and color information
- Unknown quality control for budget tier
Who Should Buy Each
Grote Semi-Hollow
- Beginner players wanting an inexpensive semi-hollow guitar
- Intermediate players looking for a mod platform with stainless frets
- Musicians who value warm, resonant tones from a semi-hollow body
- Those on a tight budget who still want a full scale instrument
Redid RD-100
- Beginners exploring semi-hollow tones
- Jazz and blues players on a budget
- Guitarists who want a 24.75 inch scale with a 42mm nut
- Buyers who value stainless steel frets
Quick Decision Guide
| If you want a semi-hollow with clearly listed dual humbuckers and a standard 3-way switch with two volume and two tone controls | Choose Redid RD-100 |
| If you prioritize a guitar with a known 22 stainless steel frets and a Canadian maple semi-hollow body | Choose Grote Semi-Hollow |
| If you play jazz, blues, or classic rock and want a traditional control layout | Choose Redid RD-100 |
| If you are willing to upgrade pickups and hardware later and want a budget platform with stainless frets | Choose Grote Semi-Hollow |
| If you want a rosewood fretboard and a specified brown finish on a semi-hollow | Choose Redid RD-100 |
FAQ
About This Comparison
Mandrillis Team
The Mandrillis editorial team researches and compares audio and music gear using manufacturer documentation, verified specs and real buyer feedback, so you can make a confident purchase without wading through marketing claims.
Read our full research methodology.
We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.