Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18 vs Zildjian A20579-11 A
Quick Verdict
Choose the Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18 if you want a curated signature pack built on cast B20 bronze with dry, textured pieces balanced by one lush extra thin crash, suited to funk, pop, fusion, and studio work. Choose the Zildjian A20579-11 A if you want a bright, crisp, matched four piece pack in the most common sizes, suited to rock, pop, worship, funk, and fusion drummers who want one predictable, professional sound everywhere. The Meinl pack scores higher overall and is the more thoroughly documented of the two, naming alloy, origin, and weight class for every piece. The Zildjian pack answers a simpler need: a consistent, bright voice across four cymbals without the dry, acquired-taste character of the Meinl set.
| Spec | Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18 | Zildjian A20579-11 A |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Signature cymbal box set, four cymbals | Four piece matched cymbal pack |
| Sizes | 14 inch hi-hats, 18 inch crash, 20 inch crash, 21 inch ride | 14 inch hi-hats, 16 inch crash, 18 inch crash, 20 inch ride |
| Alloy | Cast B20 bronze | Not published in listing |
| Finish | Not published in listing | Brilliant finish with rotary hammering |
| Weight class | Medium hi-hats, thin 18 inch crash, extra thin 20 inch crash; ride weight not published in listing | 20 inch ride is medium; hi-hat and crash weights not published in listing |
| Pack contents | 14 inch Byzance Extra Dry Medium Hihats, 18 inch Extra Dry Thin Crash, 20 inch Byzance Traditional Extra Thin Hammered Crash, 21 inch Byzance Extra Dry Transition Ride | 14 inch HiHats, 16 inch Crash, 18 inch Crash, 20 inch Medium Ride |
| Made in | Turkey, hand hammered | Not published in listing |
| Series | Byzance, Mike Johnston signature pack | A Custom |
| Sound character | Not described directly in the listing; Extra Dry pieces are known for dry, trashy, short sustaining texture and the Traditional extra thin crash for a wide musical wash | Bright, crisp, modern tones with exceptional clarity, articulate stick definition, musical highs and a sweet, refined response, per the listing |
| Included accessories | Not published in listing | Not published in listing |
Pads, Feel and Response
Since both products in this comparison are cymbal packs rather than electronic pads, feel and response come down to alloy, hammering, and weight class. The Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18 is cast B20 bronze, hand hammered in Turkey, and the listing itemizes each piece's weight class: medium hi-hats, a thin 18 inch crash, and an extra thin 20 inch crash, with the ride's weight left unpublished.
The Zildjian A20579-11 A does not publish its alloy in the listing, though it carries a brilliant finish with rotary hammering and names its 20 inch ride as medium weight, leaving the hi-hat and crash weights unstated. Response on the Zildjian pack is described as bright, crisp, and articulate with a sweet, refined character, a different feel under the stick than the Meinl's deliberately dry, textured pieces.
Drum Module and Sounds
Neither product includes a drum module, since both are acoustic cymbal packs rather than electronic kits, so tonal character comes entirely from alloy, hammering technique, and the specific cut of each cymbal. The Meinl pack scores 32 out of 35 for sound and tone, the highest single mark in this comparison, built on Extra Dry pieces known for a dry, trashy, short sustaining texture contrasted against one Traditional extra thin crash for a wider, more musical wash sound.
The Zildjian pack scores 31 out of 35, just one point behind, with the listing describing bright, crisp, modern tones, exceptional clarity, articulate stick definition, musical highs, and a sweet, refined response across all four pieces. Where the Meinl set deliberately mixes dry and lush characters piece by piece, the Zildjian set aims for a single, consistent bright voice across hi-hats, both crashes, and the ride.
Kick, Hi-Hat and Cymbal Pads
This section applies only partially, since neither pack includes a kick or hi-hat pad in the electronic sense, but both do include physical hi-hats as part of their cymbal sets. The Meinl pack's 14 inch Byzance Extra Dry Medium hi-hats are itemized by name and weight class, part of a four piece set that also includes an 18 inch Extra Dry Thin crash, a 20 inch Byzance Traditional Extra Thin Hammered crash, and a 21 inch Byzance Extra Dry Transition Ride.
The Zildjian pack's 14 inch hi-hats are itemized alongside a 16 inch crash, an 18 inch crash, and a 20 inch Medium Ride, giving it two crash sizes compared with the Meinl's two crash sizes as well, though the specific sizes differ: 16 and 18 inches on the Zildjian against 18 and 20 inches on the Meinl. Both packs cover the four most essential cymbal roles in a standard kit.
Practice Tools and Features
Neither cymbal pack includes practice tools such as mutes, cases, or stands, and neither listing mentions any hardware included at this tier. The Meinl pack's real feature is its deliberate curation: nine genres are named as suited to the set, from funk to jazz to acoustic, and the 21 inch Transition Ride is specifically built to move between a defined ride sound and a crashable wash.
The Zildjian pack's feature set centers on consistency as a matched four piece set, named for rock, pop, worship, funk, and fusion use, with a brilliant finish and rotary hammering stated as giving the set its bright character. Neither pack publishes included accessories beyond the cymbals themselves, so stands, a case, and sticks would all need to be sourced separately for either set.
Build, Rack and Footprint
The Meinl pack scores 18 out of 20 for alloy and build, backed by a stated cast B20 bronze alloy and Turkish hand hammering, both named outright in the listing. Finish is not published for the Meinl set, and the ride's weight class is also left unstated, which are the only two build details missing from an otherwise well documented pack.
The Zildjian pack scores 15 out of 20, lower than the Meinl, mainly because the alloy itself and the country of origin are not published in the listing, leaving a buyer to judge build quality from the brilliant finish and rotary hammering alone. Both packs would need the same kind of cymbal stands and a bag or case for transport, none of which is included with either, so footprint planning for a gig bag or kit case has to account for four additional cymbals regardless of which pack is chosen.
Connectivity and Recording
Connectivity does not apply to either product, since both are acoustic cymbal packs with no electronics, pickups, or outputs of any kind. Recording either pack would rely entirely on conventional overhead or room microphones, and the tonal differences described in the listings would be the main factor an engineer weighs when choosing between them for a session.
The Meinl pack's mix of dry, short sustaining pieces and one lush extra thin crash gives an engineer more tonal contrast to work with inside a single pack, useful for genres that want texture rather than uniform shimmer. The Zildjian pack's consistent bright voice across all four pieces instead gives an engineer predictability, useful when a mix calls for cymbals that sit in the same tonal lane throughout a song. Neither listing states a specific microphone pairing, so an engineer would still rely on general experience with bronze cymbals rather than any pack-specific recording guidance.
Setup and Daily Use
Daily use of the Meinl pack means handling thin and extra thin crashes with some care, since the listing itself notes that these thinner pieces need careful handling compared with heavier cymbals. The dry cymbal character is also described as an acquired taste that will not suit every player immediately, so a drummer new to Extra Dry cymbals may want to spend some time adjusting technique before a live gig.
Daily use of the Zildjian pack is more straightforward in that respect, since nothing in the listing suggests any special handling precautions for its pieces. Its bright, crisp sound is likely to read clearly in most live and studio settings without requiring the player to adjust technique for a drier, more textured tone, which makes it an easier day-to-day pack for a working drummer to pick up and play without a learning curve or extra care in transport.
The Deciding Question
The deciding question is whether the player wants dry, textured contrast across the kit or one consistent bright voice everywhere. The Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18 is built around deliberate contrast, dry pieces balanced against one lush extra thin crash, which rewards funk, pop, fusion, and studio drummers who want texture and variety from a single box.
The Zildjian A20579-11 A instead offers a single, predictable bright character across all four pieces, which suits rock, pop, worship, funk, and fusion drummers who want a cymbal pack that works the same way in every song without swapping pieces. Players who prefer dark, dry, or vintage tones should lean toward the Meinl set, while players who want a bright, modern, professional standard across the board should lean toward the Zildjian set instead.
Who Should Buy Which
Funk, R&B, pop, fusion, and studio drummers who want dry texture balanced by one lush crash in a fully documented premium pack should buy the Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18. Its stated cast B20 bronze alloy, Turkish hand hammering, and itemized weight classes make it the better documented of the two packs overall, and its higher overall score reflects that added completeness.
Rock, pop, worship, funk, and fusion drummers who want the bright professional standard in its four most common sizes should buy the Zildjian A20579-11 A. It suits players who want a bright, uniform shimmer or simply want one predictable, consistent cymbal character across the hi-hats, both crashes, and the ride without the dry, acquired-taste pieces the Meinl pack deliberately includes.
Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18
Pros
- Cast B20 bronze and Turkish hand hammering are stated outright
- Every cymbal is itemized by size, series and weight class
- Deliberate contrast between dry pieces and a lush extra thin crash
- 21 inch Transition Ride moves between defined ride and crashable wash
- Nine genres named, from funk to jazz to acoustic
Cons
- Thin and extra thin crashes need careful handling
- Dry cymbal character is an acquired taste
- Finish and ride weight are not published
- No case or hardware mentioned at this tier
Zildjian A20579-11 A
Pros
- Contents itemized with two crashes and a medium ride
- Bright, crisp, sweet A Custom voice with strong clarity
- Brilliant finish and rotary hammering stated in the listing
- Named for rock, pop, worship, funk and fusion
- Consistent voicing across the kit as a matched set
Cons
- Alloy and country of origin are not published
- Hi-hat and crash weights are unstated
- Brilliant finish shows fingerprints and stick marks
- Too bright for jazz, acoustic or dry studio tastes
Who Should Buy Each
Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18
- Funk and R&B players who want tight, dry hi-hats
- Studio drummers who need cymbals that sit cleanly in a mix
- Fusion and alternative players who want a ride that also crashes
- Admirers of Mike Johnston's approach to cymbal selection
Zildjian A20579-11 A
- Players stepping up from a B8 or brass set to a professional pack
- Worship drummers who want quick, sweet, cutting cymbals
- Funk and fusion players who prize stick definition
- Drummers who want one set for both stage and studio
Quick Decision Guide
| If you want dry, textured cymbals balanced by one lush crash | Choose Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18 |
| If you want a bright, crisp, consistent voice across all four pieces | Choose Zildjian A20579-11 A |
| If you need the alloy and country of origin confirmed in the listing | Choose Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18 |
| If you play loud metal or want a uniform bright shimmer | Choose Zildjian A20579-11 A |
| If you want a signature pack curated for funk, fusion, and studio work | Choose Meinl Percussion Meinl Cymbals MJ401+18 |
FAQ
About This Comparison
Mandrillis Team
The Mandrillis editorial team researches and compares audio and music gear using manufacturer documentation, verified specs and real buyer feedback, so you can make a confident purchase without wading through marketing claims.
Read our full research methodology.
We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.