Yamaha X vs TCL S45H
Quick Verdict
The Yamaha X and the TCL S45H are both budget-friendly Dolby Atmos soundbars, but the Yamaha adds a separate wireless subwoofer and broader wireless streaming that the TCL does not match. The Yamaha X scores 80 with up-firing drivers, dual built-in subwoofer drivers plus a separate wireless subwoofer, Wi-Fi, AirPlay 2, Spotify Connect, Bluetooth, and Alexa, though it does not publish channel count, power output, or DTS support. The TCL S45H scores 74 with up to 100 watts of confirmed power, Dolby Atmos and DTS Virtual:X processing, and HDMI eARC and ARC plus optical and AUX inputs, but no dedicated subwoofer and Bluetooth-only connectivity. Choose the Yamaha X for stronger published bass hardware and wireless streaming. Choose the TCL S45H for confirmed power output and more physical input options.
| Spec | Yamaha X | TCL S45H |
|---|---|---|
| Channels | Not published in listing | 2.0 all in one soundbar with virtual processing for height and surround |
| Drivers | Multiple drivers including up-firing units and dual built-in subwoofer drivers; exact sizes not published | Not published in listing |
| Power | Not published in listing | Up to 100W total output |
| Subwoofer | Separate wireless subwoofer included; dual subwoofer drivers built into bar | No dedicated subwoofer included and no subwoofer output listed |
| Dolby Atmos and DTS | Dolby Atmos supported; DTS support not published in listing | Dolby Atmos and DTS Virtual:X processing. Listing title also mentions DTS:X but feature bullet describes DTS Virtual:X |
| HDMI eARC and inputs | HDMI eARC connection; number of HDMI inputs not published in listing | HDMI eARC and ARC, optical, 3.5mm AUX, Bluetooth |
| Wireless and streaming | Wi-Fi, AirPlay 2, Spotify Connect, Bluetooth, Alexa voice assistant, optional wireless surrounds | Bluetooth only. No Wi-Fi, AirPlay, or Chromecast listed |
| Dimensions | Not published in listing | 31.89 inches W x 2.36 inches H x 3.86 inches D. Weight not published |
| Remote and app | Included remote control, free control app, TV remote support | Included full function remote. TCL app for setup and AI Sonic auto room calibration |
| Included accessories | Wireless subwoofer, remote control; HDMI cable not included | 1 HDMI cable, 1 power cord, 1 remote with batteries, wall mount kit |
Sound Quality
The Yamaha X's sound quality rests on up-firing drivers for Dolby Atmos, dual built-in subwoofer drivers inside the bar, and a separate wireless subwoofer included in the box. That is a notably more bass-focused hardware list than many soundbars at this tier publish, even without exact driver sizes confirmed.
The TCL S45H instead confirms up to 100 watts of total output, a specific power figure the Yamaha X's listing does not provide anywhere. The TCL has no dedicated subwoofer and no subwoofer output listed at all, so its 100 watts has to cover the full frequency range from the bar alone.
Sound Quality breakdown scores favor the Yamaha X slightly, 24 of 30 against the TCL's 23 of 30. That narrow edge tracks with the Yamaha's dual built-in subwoofer drivers plus its separate wireless subwoofer against the TCL's single bar design with no bass unit of its own at all.
Drivers, Power and Room Fit
The Yamaha X's listing names multiple drivers including up-firing units and dual built-in subwoofer drivers, though exact sizes and total power output are not published. That leaves some guesswork for a buyer trying to judge room-filling volume before the soundbar arrives at the door.
The TCL S45H does not publish driver sizes either, but it does confirm up to 100 watts total output. It also gives exact external dimensions of 31.89 inches wide, 2.36 inches tall, and 3.86 inches deep, useful for confirming fit under a television before ordering it online.
For room fit specifically, the TCL's published dimensions give a clearer physical picture than the Yamaha's listing provides. The Yamaha's separate wireless subwoofer adds bass capability that does not depend on the bar's own cabinet size at all, since it is a standalone unit placed wherever the room allows, typically in a corner or behind furniture.
Features and Connectivity
The Yamaha X supports Dolby Atmos with up-firing drivers, connects through HDMI eARC, and offers Wi-Fi, AirPlay 2, Spotify Connect, Bluetooth, and an Alexa voice assistant. It also supports optional portable wireless surrounds, though those are sold separately from the main soundbar package.
The TCL S45H supports Dolby Atmos and DTS Virtual:X processing, connects through HDMI eARC and ARC plus optical and a 3.5mm AUX input, and pairs over Bluetooth only. No Wi-Fi, AirPlay, or Chromecast support is confirmed anywhere in its published listing.
On wireless streaming specifically, the Yamaha X is the clear leader, confirming four separate protocols against the TCL's Bluetooth-only connection. The TCL counters with more physical input types, optical and AUX, that the Yamaha's listing does not mention at all, which matters for buyers connecting an older device without Bluetooth support.
Build, Design and Finish
The Yamaha X's listing does not publish dimensions or weight for the bar itself. It does confirm a separate wireless subwoofer ships in the box alongside a remote control, which adds to the overall footprint beyond just the bar.
The TCL S45H publishes full external dimensions, 31.89 by 2.36 by 3.86 inches, describing a slim, low profile design, and includes a wall mount kit. Its own weight is not stated either, so both listings leave that one figure unconfirmed.
A buyer who needs to confirm physical fit before buying has more to go on with the TCL. A buyer prioritizing a separate subwoofer unit for bass has that confirmed only in the Yamaha's listing, not the TCL's, which is a meaningful tradeoff depending on what matters most during setup.
Setup and Placement
The Yamaha X includes a remote control and a free control app, plus TV remote support. Its wireless subwoofer needs only a power outlet rather than a cable run back to the bar itself, simplifying placement in most living rooms.
The TCL S45H ships with a full function remote and uses its TCL app for setup along with AI Sonic automatic room calibration. It also includes a wall mount kit for buyers who do not want it sitting on a shelf.
Both soundbars support app-based setup, but the TCL's AI Sonic calibration is a named, specific room-tuning feature. The Yamaha X's listing does not describe an equivalent calibration feature for its own app in the same amount of detail, leaving that part of the setup process less clearly documented.
Daily Use
Daily use on the Yamaha X benefits from Clear Voice dialogue enhancement and from streaming music directly over Wi-Fi, AirPlay 2, or Spotify Connect. That works without needing a connected source device turned on nearby, which matters for casual background listening.
Daily use on the TCL S45H is more limited to sources that reach it over HDMI, optical, AUX, or Bluetooth, since no Wi-Fi or AirPlay is confirmed. A phone or computer must handle any streaming app directly before the sound ever reaches the bar itself.
For a household that streams music often without a TV or source device already on, the Yamaha X's wireless streaming protocols make a real daily difference. That is a gap the TCL cannot match on paper given its Bluetooth-only connectivity, which still requires a nearby paired device for every listening session.
Who Should Buy It
The Yamaha X's own best for guidance names buyers who want a budget Dolby Atmos soundbar with a wireless subwoofer and clear dialogue, without buying rear surrounds upfront as part of the initial purchase. That keeps the entry cost lower while leaving room to expand later with optional portable wireless surrounds if the buyer decides they want them.
The TCL S45H's own best for guidance names budget buyers who want a simple single soundbar with virtual Dolby Atmos and DTS processing, eARC connectivity, and auto room calibration for a small or medium room. That is a narrower, more budget-focused profile than the Yamaha's, aimed squarely at a straightforward TV sound upgrade rather than a broader music setup.
The Deciding Question
With scores of 80 against 74, the Yamaha X has a real published edge. It comes mostly from its separate wireless subwoofer and its broader wireless streaming support, both of which the TCL's listing does not match on paper.
The TCL S45H's advantages are narrower but real: a confirmed 100 watt power figure, published dimensions, and more physical input types. If you specifically need those confirmed figures over wireless streaming breadth, the TCL's listing gives you more to verify before buying it.
Neither advantage is decisive on its own, so the right choice depends on whether confirmed numbers or broader wireless features matter more to how you plan to actually use the soundbar day to day. A buyer who mostly watches TV through the bar may lean toward the TCL's confirmed power, while a buyer who streams music constantly throughout the day may lean toward the Yamaha's wider set of wireless protocols instead.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the Yamaha X if you want a budget Dolby Atmos soundbar with a separate wireless subwoofer, broad wireless streaming through Wi-Fi, AirPlay 2, and Spotify Connect, and Alexa voice control. It fits best when you are comfortable with some specs left unpublished in exchange for that broader feature set and the convenience it brings to daily listening.
Buy the TCL S45H if you want a confirmed 100 watt power figure, published physical dimensions, optical and AUX inputs alongside HDMI, and automatic room calibration. It fits best when you prioritize documented numbers over wireless streaming breadth in your final decision.
Neither soundbar publishes a complete specification sheet, so a buyer prioritizing transparency on one specific figure, power for the TCL or subwoofer hardware for the Yamaha, should let that specific gap guide the final decision between the two. Reading both listings side by side, rather than relying on the overall score alone, is the more reliable way to choose.
Yamaha X
Pros
- Dolby Atmos with up-firing drivers
- Wireless subwoofer included in the box
- Dual built-in subwoofer drivers in the bar
- Clear Voice dialogue enhancement
- Wi-Fi, AirPlay 2 and Spotify Connect
- Optional portable wireless surrounds
Cons
- Exact channel count and power output not published
- DTS support not stated
- HDMI cable not included
- Driver sizes and dimensions not published
- Optional surrounds sold separately
TCL S45H
Pros
- Virtual Dolby Atmos and DTS Virtual:X processing from a single bar
- Up to 100W output for a budget 2.0 soundbar
- AI Sonic automatic room calibration via the TCL app
- HDMI eARC and ARC plus optical, Bluetooth, and AUX inputs
- Slim low profile design with wall mount kit included
- Full function remote and simple plug and play setup
Cons
- No dedicated subwoofer limits bass depth
- Driver sizes and frequency response not published
- No Wi-Fi streaming or AirPlay and Chromecast support
- Surround and height effects are simulated, not discrete channels
- No published weight or exact HDMI version
Who Should Buy Each
Yamaha X
- Shoppers who want Atmos height effects on a budget
- People who value clear dialogue for movies and shows
- Buyers who want a wireless subwoofer included in the box
- Those who plan to add Yamaha True X wireless surrounds later
TCL S45H
- Apartment and bedroom users who want clearer TV sound without extra speakers
- Buyers with a TV that supports HDMI eARC or ARC and want an easy single cable upgrade
- Listeners who value automatic room calibration at a budget price
- People who plan to wall mount a soundbar below a TV
Quick Decision Guide
| If you want a separate wireless subwoofer included in the box | Choose Yamaha X |
| If you want a confirmed power output figure | Choose TCL S45H |
| If you want Wi-Fi, AirPlay 2, and Spotify Connect streaming | Choose Yamaha X |
| If you want optical and AUX inputs alongside HDMI | Choose TCL S45H |
| If you want Alexa voice assistant support built in | Choose Yamaha X |
FAQ
About This Comparison
Mandrillis Team
The Mandrillis editorial team researches and compares audio and music gear using manufacturer documentation, verified specs and real buyer feedback, so you can make a confident purchase without wading through marketing claims.
Read our full research methodology.
We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.