MANDRILLIS Better Gear. Better Sound.

Zildjian A20579-11 A vs Stagg MYR-CR17B US

Quick Verdict

The Zildjian A20579-11 A scores 84 against the Stagg MYR-CR17B US's 82, with the Zildjian winning on versatility and pack completeness while the Stagg wins on alloy transparency and value. The Zildjian is a four piece matched pack with 14 inch hi-hats, a 16 inch crash, an 18 inch crash, and a 20 inch medium ride, all in a brilliant finish with a bright, crisp A Custom voice. The Stagg is a single 17 inch rock crash made from cast B20 bronze, a specific alloy the listing confirms outright, at a budget price point. Choose the Zildjian if you need a complete, matched cymbal setup in one purchase, and the Stagg if you want one loud, durable B20 crash at a lower price and do not mind unpublished weight and finish details.

Spec Zildjian A20579-11 A Stagg MYR-CR17B US
Type Four piece matched cymbal pack Rock crash cymbal
Sizes 14 inch hi-hats, 16 inch crash, 18 inch crash, 20 inch ride 17 inch
Alloy Not published in listing B20 bronze
Finish Brilliant finish with rotary hammering Not published in listing
Weight class 20 inch ride is medium; hi-hat and crash weights not published in listing Not published in listing (described as a rock crash)
Pack contents 14 inch HiHats, 16 inch Crash, 18 inch Crash, 20 inch Medium Ride One 17 inch rock crash cymbal
Made in Not published in listing Not published in listing (designed in Europe)
Series A Custom Myra
Sound character Bright, crisp, modern tones with exceptional clarity, articulate stick definition, musical highs and a sweet, refined response, per the listing Not published in listing
Included accessories Not published in listing Not published in listing

Pads, Feel and Response

The Zildjian A20579-11 A pack is described as producing bright, crisp, modern tones with exceptional clarity, articulate stick definition, musical highs, and a sweet, refined response, all stated directly in the listing. That description applies across all four pieces, since this is sold as a matched set rather than individually voiced cymbals, which means a drummer should expect a consistent brightness whether they are riding, crashing, or playing the hi-hats.

The Stagg MYR-CR17B US has no tonal description published in its listing at all, leaving sound character to be inferred from its rock crash designation and its cast B20 bronze alloy, both of which generally point toward a louder, fuller voice than a thinner crash. A rock crash designation typically also means it needs a firm stroke to open up fully, which the listing itself notes as a consideration. Without a published tonal description, a buyer is relying more heavily on the alloy and category label than on any specific marketing claim about how the cymbal actually sounds.

Drum Module and Sounds

This category does not apply in the traditional electronic kit sense, since both products are acoustic cymbals with no module or sample library. Their sound comes entirely from alloy, shape, weight, and finish rather than any digital component, so there is no sample count or kit list to compare the way there would be for an electronic drum set.

The Zildjian's four pieces together form a cohesive package meant to cover an entire cymbal setup, with hi-hats, two crash sizes, and a ride, so the listing frames the voicing as consistent across the kit as a matched set. The Stagg, as a single crash cymbal, has no equivalent matched set claim since it is sold and used as one standalone piece rather than a coordinated group, so its sound stands entirely on its own without needing to blend with other cymbals from the same line.

Kick, Hi-Hat and Cymbal Pads

The Zildjian pack itemizes its contents clearly: 14 inch hi-hats, a 16 inch crash, an 18 inch crash, and a 20 inch medium ride, giving a drummer every standard cymbal size needed for rock, pop, worship, funk, and fusion playing in one purchase. The 20 inch ride's medium weight is specifically published, though the hi-hat and crash weights are not stated, which leaves some detail about exact feel and volume for those three pieces unconfirmed.

The Stagg is a single 17 inch rock crash, a size that sits usefully between the more common 16 and 18 inch options, giving a player a specific in-between voice rather than a full set. It has no hi-hat or ride included at all, so a buyer would need to source those separately if building a complete setup around this one crash, which is an important budgeting point for anyone assuming this purchase covers an entire cymbal setup on its own.

Practice Tools and Features

Neither cymbal pack includes any training app, metronome, or electronic practice feature, since both are purely acoustic hardware. The Zildjian's brilliant finish and rotary hammering are described in the listing as part of its sound and appearance, not as practice aids, though the consistent four piece voicing does mean a student practicing dynamics across the kit gets a uniform response to learn from.

The Stagg's listing notes it is designed in Europe and uses cast B20 bronze, both specific manufacturing details, but offers no practice related feature either. For either product, practice value comes entirely from how the cymbals sound and respond under a stick, not from any built in tool, so a player choosing between them should weigh response and durability rather than any added practice feature.

Build, Rack and Footprint

The Zildjian pack's alloy is not published in the listing, which is a notable gap for a cymbal pack where alloy composition strongly shapes tone, though its brilliant finish with rotary hammering is confirmed. Country of origin is also not published for the Zildjian pack, so a buyer cannot confirm where in the world these four pieces were actually produced.

The Stagg crash confirms its cast B20 bronze alloy directly, which is a meaningful piece of transparency the Zildjian's listing does not match, even though the Stagg's finish, weight class, and country of manufacture are all left unstated. Between the two, the Stagg discloses the more fundamental material fact, while the Zildjian discloses more about finish and surface treatment, so each listing is strong on a different kind of build detail rather than one being comprehensively documented and the other not.

Connectivity and Recording

Neither product has any electronic connectivity, since both are entirely acoustic cymbals with no module, MIDI, USB, or Bluetooth feature. Any recording involving either product would happen through external microphones placed around the kit, with microphone choice and placement affecting the captured sound far more than anything the cymbal itself could offer.

This category does not meaningfully distinguish the two, since cymbals in general have no built in recording or digital interface regardless of brand or price tier. The comparison here stays focused on alloy, size, and published tonal description instead, which are the factors that actually separate one cymbal from another in practice.

Setup and Daily Use

Day to day, the Zildjian pack gives a gigging or recording drummer a complete, predictable cymbal voice across hi-hats, two crashes, and a ride, which the listing frames as suited to rock, pop, worship, funk, and fusion without needing to mix and match brands. Its brilliant finish is noted elsewhere in the listing as showing fingerprints and stick marks more readily than a traditional finish, which means more frequent cleaning for a player who wants it looking new, and that upkeep is a fair tradeoff against the convenience of buying one matched set instead of four separate cymbals.

The Stagg crash suits a heavier hitting rock, punk, or metal player who wants one loud, durable B20 crash and is comfortable filling in the rest of their setup separately. Because it needs a firm stroke to open fully, a quieter or more delicate player may find it does not respond the way a thinner, lighter crash would under a lighter touch, so matching playing style to the cymbal's described character matters more here than with a brighter, more general purpose pack.

The Deciding Question

The deciding question between the Zildjian A20579-11 A and the Stagg MYR-CR17B US is whether you need a complete, matched cymbal setup or a single, specific crash at a lower price. The Zildjian's higher overall score of 84 against the Stagg's 82 reflects its stronger versatility and pack completeness scores, since it covers hi-hats, two crashes, and a ride in one purchase with a consistent, bright A Custom voice.

The Stagg answers a narrower but still real need: a single cast B20 bronze rock crash at a budget price, with a confirmed alloy the Zildjian's listing does not state for its own pieces. If you already own hi-hats and a ride and just need one loud crash, the Stagg's focused, lower cost offering may suit you better than buying an entire four piece pack.

Who Should Buy Which

Choose the Zildjian A20579-11 A if you want a complete four piece cymbal pack with hi-hats, two crashes, and a ride in one purchase, a bright and crisp A Custom voice, and you play rock, pop, worship, funk, or fusion.

Choose the Stagg MYR-CR17B US if you want a single, confirmed cast B20 bronze rock crash at a budget price, you already own the rest of your cymbal setup, and you play heavier styles like rock, punk, or metal where a loud, durable crash matters most, even without a published weight figure or tonal description to lean on beforehand.

Zildjian A20579-11 A

Pros

  • Contents itemized with two crashes and a medium ride
  • Bright, crisp, sweet A Custom voice with strong clarity
  • Brilliant finish and rotary hammering stated in the listing
  • Named for rock, pop, worship, funk and fusion
  • Consistent voicing across the kit as a matched set

Cons

  • Alloy and country of origin are not published
  • Hi-hat and crash weights are unstated
  • Brilliant finish shows fingerprints and stick marks
  • Too bright for jazz, acoustic or dry studio tastes

Stagg MYR-CR17B US

Pros

  • Cast B20 bronze alloy confirmed in the listing
  • 17 inch size sits usefully between 16 and 18
  • Rock crash designation points to a heavier, louder build
  • Budget price tier for a B20 cymbal
  • Designed in Europe according to the listing

Cons

  • No weight figure, thickness or finish published
  • Country of manufacture not stated
  • No tonal description in the listing
  • Rock crashes need a firm stroke to open fully

Who Should Buy Each

Zildjian A20579-11 A

  • Players stepping up from a B8 or brass set to a professional pack
  • Worship drummers who want quick, sweet, cutting cymbals
  • Funk and fusion players who prize stick definition
  • Drummers who want one set for both stage and studio

Stagg MYR-CR17B US

  • Rock and metal drummers who need a crash that survives heavy hitting
  • Players replacing a sheet brass crash from a starter pack
  • Drummers who want a 17 inch crash to sit between a 16 and an 18
  • Anyone who wants a cast B20 crash on a budget

Quick Decision Guide

If you need a complete four piece cymbal pack in one purchase Choose Zildjian A20579-11 A
If you want a confirmed B20 bronze alloy at a budget price Choose Stagg MYR-CR17B US
If you play rock, pop, worship, funk or fusion and want a bright, versatile voice Choose Zildjian A20579-11 A
If you already own hi-hats and a ride and just need one loud crash Choose Stagg MYR-CR17B US
If you want the higher overall published score between the two Choose Zildjian A20579-11 A

FAQ

The listing states 14 inch hi-hats, a 16 inch crash, an 18 inch crash, and a 20 inch medium ride, giving a drummer a full standard cymbal setup in one matched purchase.
The listing confirms cast B20 bronze, a specific alloy commonly used in higher quality cymbals. This is more alloy transparency than the Zildjian pack's listing provides for its own pieces.
The listing describes a bright, crisp, modern voice better suited to rock, pop, worship, funk, and fusion. Its own avoid-if note states it may be too bright for jazz, acoustic, or dry studio tastes.
No. The listing describes it only as a rock crash designation without a stated weight class, thickness, or finish, so buyers should expect a loud, full voice based on the alloy and category alone.
The Stagg MYR-CR17B US scores higher on value at 9 out of 10 against the Zildjian pack's 7 out of 10, reflecting its lower price point for a confirmed B20 bronze alloy cymbal.
Zildjian A20579-11 A last verified: October 2026 Stagg MYR-CR17B US last verified: October 2026

About This Comparison

M

Mandrillis Team

The Mandrillis editorial team researches and compares audio and music gear using manufacturer documentation, verified specs and real buyer feedback, so you can make a confident purchase without wading through marketing claims.

Read our full research methodology.

We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.