Donner DEP-20 vs Alesis Recital Pro
Quick Verdict
Choose the Donner DEP-20 if you want the most features for the least money: 238 voices, 2 x 25 W speakers, a screen, dual headphone jacks and a pedal in the box. Choose the Alesis Recital Pro if you want the slightly better piano tone, quarter-inch line outputs and battery operation, with a bigger brand behind it. Both have budget hammer actions that trail Casio and Yamaha; between the two, the Donner is the value pick and the Alesis the safer one.
| Spec | Donner DEP-20 | Alesis Recital Pro |
|---|---|---|
| Key Action | Hammer action, 88 weighted keys | Hammer action, 88 full-size keys |
| Sound Engine | Sampled voices | Sampled voices |
| Voices | 238 | 12 |
| Polyphony | 128 notes | 128 notes |
| Speakers | 2 x 25 W | 2 x 20 W |
| Bluetooth | No | No |
| USB | USB MIDI | USB MIDI |
| Pedals | Sustain pedal included | Sustain input (pedal not included) |
| Weight | 25.6 lb (11.6 kg) per listing | 23.1 lb (10.5 kg) per listing |
| Form Factor | Portable | Portable, battery capable |
The Budget Hammer-Action Pair
These are the two cheapest hammer-action 88s that most buyers consider, and they are usually within a few dollars of each other. Both have screens, layer and split modes, recording, USB MIDI and loud built-in speakers. The Donner adds a huge voice library and a pedal in the box; the Alesis adds line outputs and battery power. Neither has Bluetooth.
Action
Both use hammer-weighted keys with adjustable touch and both are heavier and more uniform than the graded actions in the Casio CDP-S160 or Yamaha P-145. The Alesis action returns a little faster; the Donner's is marginally heavier. Neither has textured keys or escapement. For a beginner either does the job of building finger strength; for an intermediate player both will feel limiting within a couple of years.
Sounds
The Donner's 238 voices cover almost every instrument category and most are usable; its main grand piano is the weak point, thinner than the Alesis's. The Alesis has twelve voices with a slightly fuller piano and good electric pianos. Both have 128-note polyphony. If the keyboard will be used for exploring sounds and playing along to songs, the Donner's library is a real advantage; if it will be used mostly as a piano, the Alesis's tone is the better of two modest samples.
Speakers and Outputs
The Donner's 2 x 25 W speakers are a touch louder than the Alesis's 2 x 20 W, and both fill a family room. The Alesis adds quarter-inch left and right line outputs for an amplifier or interface; the Donner has a single stereo output jack. The Donner has two headphone jacks; the Alesis one.
Screen, Recording and Extras
Both have backlit LCDs that show voices and settings. Both record a performance internally. The Donner includes a sustain switch pedal and a music rest; the Alesis includes a music rest only. The Alesis bundles Skoove and Melodics subscriptions; the Donner bundles its own lesson app access.
Power and Portability
The Alesis runs on six D batteries as well as mains power; the Donner is mains-only. Weights are similar at around 23 to 26 pounds. Both suit any X-stand and both makers sell matching furniture stands and three-pedal units.
Brand and Support
Alesis is part of the inMusic group with a long history in keyboards and a wide dealer network; Donner is a younger direct-to-consumer brand that has grown quickly on price. Both offer warranties; the Alesis has the longer track record for parts and service.
Lesson and Practice Features
Both keyboards split into two identical zones for teacher and student, both have metronomes with visible tempo on the screen, and both record a performance for playback. The Donner adds two headphone jacks so a parent can listen alongside, and its screen is a little more informative about layers and splits. The Alesis bundles Skoove and Melodics subscriptions, which give a self-taught beginner a structured start over the USB connection. Neither has Bluetooth, so apps need a cable on both.
Speakers, Rooms and Outputs
Both are loud enough for a family room, which is unusual at this price, and both will reach a small classroom. The Alesis's quarter-inch left and right outputs feed a keyboard amp, mixer or interface without touching the headphone jack; the Donner's single stereo output does the same with a splitter cable. For a church hall or a school, the Alesis's outputs and battery option are the practical advantages; for a living room, the Donner's extra headphone jack is.
Long-Term Ownership
Both are keyboards families keep for a few years and then pass on when a student becomes serious. The Donner's voice library keeps younger children engaged longer; the Alesis's slightly better piano tone keeps an adult beginner happier. Neither becomes a long-term piano for a classical student, and both resell quickly at a modest loss. If the budget can reach a Casio CDP-S160 or Yamaha P-145, the step up in action and tone is worth more than any feature either of these offers.
Build Quality and Warranty
Both keyboards use plastic chassis with glossy panels and feel similar in hand. The Donner's included pedal is a lightweight switch that slides on hard floors; the Alesis leaves the pedal to you, which means buying a better one anyway. Donner sells direct and through Amazon with a standard warranty and a growing support operation; Alesis has decades of distribution behind it and spare parts are easier to find. For a keyboard that will be used by children, the extra headphone jack on the Donner and the battery option on the Alesis are each small practical wins.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the Donner DEP-20 for a family keyboard that must do everything cheaply, with a pedal included and the loudest speakers. Buy the Alesis Recital Pro for a piano-first budget keyboard with line outputs, battery power and a more established brand. If the budget can reach the Casio CDP-S160, its action and piano tone are a clear step above both.
Donner DEP-20
Pros
- 238 voices and 2 x 25 W speakers at a budget price
- Hammer-action keys with a sustain pedal in the box
- LCD with recording, metronome and layering
- Dual headphone jacks
Cons
- Action is heavy and uniform rather than graded
- Piano sample is thin next to Yamaha, Casio and Korg
- No Bluetooth or USB audio
Alesis Recital Pro
Pros
- Hammer action at the lowest price in this guide
- Powerful 2 x 20 W speakers
- LCD screen makes settings easy
- Quarter-inch line outputs and battery operation
Cons
- Action is heavier and less refined than Yamaha, Casio or Roland
- Only twelve voices and no Bluetooth
- No pedal in the box
Who Should Buy Each
Donner DEP-20
- You want the most features for the least money
- You play pop and keyboard parts as much as piano
- You need loud speakers for a family room
Alesis Recital Pro
- You want weighted keys on a strict budget
- You need speakers loud enough for a living room
- You want a screen rather than hold-and-press settings
Quick Decision Guide
| If you want the most voices and a pedal in the box | Choose Donner DEP-20 |
| If you want line outputs and battery power | Choose Alesis Recital Pro |
| If the piano tone matters more than the sound library | Choose Alesis Recital Pro |
| If you need two headphone jacks | Choose Donner DEP-20 |
| If brand support and dealer network matter | Choose Alesis Recital Pro |
FAQ
About This Comparison
Mandrillis Team
The Mandrillis editorial team researches and compares audio and music gear using manufacturer documentation, verified specs and real buyer feedback, so you can make a confident purchase without wading through marketing claims.
Read our full research methodology.
We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.